Welcome to Pony Express Pizza
At Pony Express Pizza, nestled in Henderson, KY, our story is rooted in a passion for crafting exceptional pizza and sandwiches that deliver an all-American experience. With new ownership infusing fresh energy, we’ve revitalized our menu, introducing exciting items alongside classic favorites. Our skilled team ensures quick service and a warm welcome, as echoed by our loyal customers. From our signature pizzas to delectable sides like loaded cheese sticks and tasty drinks, every bite speaks to our commitment to quality and taste. Join us for a slice of nostalgia blended with innovation, where every meal is a heartfelt experience.
Pony Express Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Great pizza. Employees great you and not a long wait if you call in an order and pick up
Amazing food service. They recently changed owners are doing an amazing job!
In the world of Pizza, Pony Express offers something unique and very American. I havent eaten here long, so, I cannot speak on consistency or anything like that. But I can tell when a place has crafted something of their own. I can ...
I have loved pony express ever since I was a kid. Unfortunately, over time it just kind of ... fell off a bit. But I just went back since the new owners and Im SUPER impressed! The menu had new items and the staff was awesome and even helped ...
Best pizza place in town... eat here every Wednesday night like clock work
First time trying this establishment again under the new ownership. Pizza was fast, great and available on a Saturday night. Staff was prompt and polite. I couldnt help but notice they were answering phones and taking deliveries like it was 2005 again. Might be too early to call it, but I think we are back.
Disagree with all of the bad reviews this place has. They stick to pizza because thats what they are, a pizza place. Pizza is what they do and its just really good simple pizza, for that reason Im never disappointed. Furthermore the ...
Pony Express is by far the best pizza joint in town! Cooked to perfection, you can clearly tell that they use the absolute best and most fresh ingredients. Service was very quick and timely. Also, Annie, Angie, and their staff are so friendly and generous! Most definitely give this place a try if you havent already!
Location
-
343 3rd St, Henderson, KY 42420 Hotline: (270) 826-2770
Welcome to the delicious world of Pony Express Pizza, a charming pizzeria located at 343 3rd St, Henderson, KY 42420. This gem of a restaurant specializes in crafting mouthwatering pizzas that satisfy every craving, from indulgent meat lovers to fresh veggie enthusiasts.
Pony Express Pizza thrives on its unique menu, offering a variety of flavorful specialties that are sure to please any palate. Here are a few highlights you won’t want to miss:
- All Meat Pizza: For carnivores, this pie features a hearty blend of ground beef, ham, bacon, sausage, Italian sausage, and pepperoni. It's a meat lover's paradise!
- Taco Pizza: This creative option includes taco meat, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses, topped with a generous serving of thick salsa, lettuce, and tomatoes.
- All Cheese Pizza: A dream for cheese lovers, this indulgent creation features a blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, muenster, Monterey jack, and Romano cheeses.
- Vegetable Pizza: A delightful medley of onions, green peppers, black olives, mushrooms, and jalapenos ensures that veggie fans are well catered for.
- Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza: This creation combines ground beef, bacon, and a special blend of cheeses to satisfy your burger cravings—all on a pizza!
The culinary offerings don’t stop at pizza! Pony Express Pizza also features an array of delectable sides, including cheesesticks, pretzel sticks with cheese sauce, and loaded cheese sticks to complement your meal. When it comes to drinks, their selection ranges from classic favorites like Coca-Cola to unique options like Mellow Yellow.
Customer feedback speaks volumes about Pony Express Pizza's commitment to quality and service. Patrons rave about their amazing food, friendly staff, and quick order turnaround. Recent ownership changes have sparked a fresh energy at the restaurant, leading to an exciting selection of newly introduced dishes that keep diners coming back. Just ask longtime customers like Desiree Doll, who was thrilled by the revamped menu and the engaging service.
Pony Express Pizza represents not just a place to eat, but a local treasure where community meets flavor. Every bite speaks to the care and creativity put into crafting each dish. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a quick pickup, Pony Express Pizza is poised to deliver an unforgettable experience.
For inquiries, you can reach them at (270) 826-2770. Come and discover why this charming pizzeria is hailed as the best in town!
